GTA 6's Criminal Profile Runs From Professional to Psycho
GTA 6 keeps score of what kind of criminal you are. From a three-hour preview at Rockstar North, the Criminal Profile has four states, and pushing past the last one breaks it.

What is the criminal profile in GTA 6?

The notifications that pop up on the side of the screen in the Extended Look belong to the criminal profile, a new GTA system that grades what kind of criminal you are. It is not Red Dead Redemption 2's honor, Rob Nelson said.
Asked whether it changes the story, Nelson said it may, depending on how you play: there is no right or wrong way, "just a little bit more choice now."
It does not stop you causing chaos: in Nelson's words it does not change what GTA is, only what it can be for players who want to play that way.
What are the criminal profile states?
There are four, from best to worst: Professional, Aggressive, Violent and Psycho. They are states, not a bar that moves with every act as honor did in Red Dead 2.
Below Psycho there is a last state: commit enough heinous acts and the profile icon cracks, then shatters, and stays that way for the rest of the playthrough. It is hard to reach on purpose.
The September 29 cover story names the scale differently, from Professional to Irredeemable, and does not say how Irredeemable lines up with these four states. More from that story: GTA 6 cover story.
Rockstar's reason: in Red Dead 2 you could kill thousands, then pet a few dogs before the last chapter and be a good man again. The locked state is for players who do not want the system at all, not a punishment.
The current state shows at the bottom right of the screen and in a Jason and Lucia tab of the menu, next to their relationship status.
How do you keep a Professional criminal profile?

"Restraint, control", Nelson said: in a robbery, control the people and the situation, and do not kill or injure anyone unless you have to. How to run a clean hold-up is on GTA 6 store robbery.
Jason and Lucia each have their own profile. One run can keep both Professional, another make both Psycho, or split them, and the states may change how some story moments play out.
The notifications can be switched off, and what you see from the system appears to be customizable in the settings.
What it changes in the game
The four states are Professional, Aggressive, Violent and Psycho. Restraint, few deaths and clean escapes keep you Professional; killing and chaos push you down the scale.
Go far enough and the profile icon cracks, then shatters, and stays locked that way for the rest of the playthrough.
Jason and Lucia each have their own profile, so one can stay Professional while the other turns Psycho.
The notifications can be switched off, and ignoring the system brings no forced penalty.
Still unknown: What each state changes in the game, beyond the label.
Frequently asked
Does GTA 6 have an honor system?
Not Red Dead's honor. GTA 6 has a criminal profile with four states, Professional, Aggressive, Violent and Psycho, which describe how you commit crimes rather than judge you.
Can you turn off the criminal profile in GTA 6?
You can switch off its notifications. Reaching the shattered state below Psycho also effectively turns the system off for that playthrough.
Does the criminal profile change GTA 6's story?
It may, depending on how you play, Rob Nelson said: each lead's profile can change how some story moments play out.
